File Name: situation ethics strengths and weaknesses .zip
British Broadcasting Corporation Home. Situation ethics teaches that ethical decisions should follow flexible guidelines rather than absolute rules, and be taken on a case by case basis. There are no universal moral rules or rights - each case is unique and deserves a unique solution.
- Chapter 5. Fletcher’s Situation Ethics
- Relativism and Absolutism – Strengths and Weaknesses
- major strengths and weaknesses of ethics of care
- The strengths and weaknesses of Situation Ethics
You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account.
Skip to content. It is clear the majority would agree the weaknesses do outweigh the strengths of situation ethics, the weaknesses show why it has not been adopted by mainstream moral thinking in any of the major Christian churches. Situationist thinking can be seen as a response to the collapse of many moral certainties as well as the inadequacies of legalistic moral thinking but it would be more applicable to take a different approach. Report Thu 30th April,
Chapter 5. Fletcher’s Situation Ethics
Skip to content. It is clear the majority would agree the weaknesses do outweigh the strengths of situation ethics, the weaknesses show why it has not been adopted by mainstream moral thinking in any of the major Christian churches. Situationist thinking can be seen as a response to the collapse of many moral certainties as well as the inadequacies of legalistic moral thinking but it would be more applicable to take a different approach.
Report Thu 30th April, Sign up to Comment. Similar Philosophy resources: Situation Ethics. Situation ethics.
Situation Ethics. Christian Ethics. Ethics- Kant. Utilitarianism Full Notes. Ethics and Theology. Absolutism and Relativism. The strengths and weaknesses of Situation Ethics. It fits in with 'philosophy and practical ethics' because of Jesus in the New Testament. Jesus broke the religious rules and dealt with everyone as individuals and according to circumstances.
Bases it's decisions upon Christ's statement that the whole of the law was summoned by the command that we ought to love our neighbour. In the greatest commandment, one of the Pharisees tested him as to what was the greatest commandment, he replied 'love the lord your god with all your heart and with all your soul and mind' this is the greatest- the second greatest is- 'love your neighbour as yourself' IT IS FLEXIBLE As opposed to a legalistic, who follows the absolutes, and believes they must tell the truth could one day be faced with a murderer who wanted to find out where their wife was, they would be in an impossible position and most likely go against their approach.
The biggest issue is that there will always be a dispute as to what is the most loving action and what this actually means in practice, everyone is subjective and have their own interpretations of different things and could see one thing as loving and another not that someone else may object. If two people using this system of ethics came to opposite conclusions as to what they should do, there is no way there dilemma could be solved because it rejects the absolute rules that could guide their actions.
We need a specific or definitive idea of what outcome is the most valued, right before we can decide upon which acts are needed to bring about the right thing. Evaluation It is clear the majority would agree the weaknesses do outweigh the strengths of situation ethics, the weaknesses show why it has not been adopted by mainstream moral thinking in any of the major Christian churches.
Relativism and Absolutism – Strengths and Weaknesses
Skip to content. Situation Ethics is great in principle, surely it can only be right to do the most loving act? It allows for flexibility which may make it popular because lots of ethical issues are individual and require different responses to different situations. But it could also be seen as too idealistic, love is subjective and not everyone knows what constitutes a loving act. Discarding absolute laws would not work in society.
People like to wallow or cower in the security of the law. Every man must decide for himself according to his own estimate of conditions and consequences … 2. At the time it was written it seemed to make some radical claims such as that it is not wrong to have extramarital sex, to be homosexual, or to have an abortion. It is badly argued, idiosyncratic and rehashes old ideas. However, the Pharisees tell him off because he has performed this healing on the Sabbath day and the Jewish law says that no one can work on the Sabbath. Fletcher has in mind a simple minded deontologist who holds that actions are right and wrong irrespective of the consequences.
So, here it is. Relativism is the theory which stated that there are no absolute truths; truth is relative to the subject and can vary from person to person and from society to society. There are no universally valid moral principles and so there is no one true morality. All principles and values are relative to a particular culture and age. Truth is relative. Certain actions are intrinsically right or wrong right or wrong in themselves.
major strengths and weaknesses of ethics of care
There are no justifiable actions which allow you to encourage or participate in the harm of another person, even if that individual is trying to hurt you at that time. The Categorical Imperative is a powerful set of principles that prohibit acts that would commonly be considered wrong, … We do not have to know all of the consequences of an action to know whether it is wrong. Strengths and weaknesses: easier to apply. While Kant believed in his own theory that moral rules are absolute EMP
Situation ethics was most famously championed by Joseph Fletcher It is based on agape love Christian unconditional love , and says that we should always do the most loving thing in any situation.
The strengths and weaknesses of Situation Ethics
- Директор выдержал паузу. Никто не проронил ни слова. Он снова посмотрел на Джаббу и закрыл. - Танкадо отдал кольцо с умыслом. Мне все равно, думал ли он, что тучный господин побежит к телефону-автомату и позвонит нам, или просто хотел избавиться от этого кольца. Я принял решение. Мы вводим эту цитату.
Куда бы ни падал его взгляд, всюду мелькали красно-бело-синие прически. Тела танцующих слились так плотно, что он не мог рассмотреть, во что они одеты. Британского флага нигде не было .
Стратмор проследил за ее взглядом и нахмурился Он надеялся, что Сьюзан не заметит эту контрольную панель. Эта светящаяся клавиатура управляла его личным лифтом. Стратмор и его высокопоставленные посетители попадали в шифровалку и уходили незаметно для остальных сотрудников. Лифт спускался на пятьдесят ярдов вниз и затем двигался вбок по укрепленному туннелю еще сто девять ярдов в подземное помещение основного комплекса агентства. Лифт, соединяющий шифровалку с основным зданием, получал питание из главного комплекса, и оно действовало, несмотря на отключение питания шифровалки. Стратмору, разумеется, это было хорошо известно, но даже когда Сьюзан порывалась уйти через главный выход, он не обмолвился об этом ни единым словом. Он не мог пока ее отпустить - время еще не пришло.